Writing
Agentic Commerce: Why X402 is Just the Beginning
on
| Click to read translation here:
Read Full Proposal
Read Blueprint

Agentic economy

By 2030, AI agents are projected to surpass $1 trillion in US retail transactions alone. Globally, this number can reach $3 to $5 trillion. This isn't a distant future but the agentic economy, where AI agents will handle everything from comparing mortgage rates to negotiating your car purchase, fundamentally reshaping how commerce works. Agents will be able to find, compare, and make purchases for customers. This transition will require a complete overhaul of how businesses operate as agents will be the primary means through which humans interact with the market.  

Why today's business models fail agents

Current businesses are set up to serve the needs of human beings. As we move towards an agentic society, businesses will need to adopt new strategies for discoverability, marketing, monetization, retention and engagement to serve agents acting on behalf of users. The current modern internet economy runs primarily on attention, access, and intermediation.

  1. Attention based (Google, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok) fuels the free internet
  2. Access based (SaaS, Subscriptions, AI APIs) dominate B2B and premium consumer services
  3. Intermediation based (Uber, Airbnb, App Store, Uniswap) dominate transactional ecosystems

These models share a common assumption: a human is always in the loop, clicking, subscribing, or authorizing. Agents break this assumption and face many challenges in current set up:  

  • Authorization: Current business models require extensive user onboarding, verification process, legacy payment setups before the service can be accessed. Agents can't fill out CAPTCHA forms, verify their identity through SMS codes, or navigate multifactor authentication. While a human might create 5-10 accounts per year, an agent optimizing user could need access to hundreds of services daily.
  • Micropayments: For most businesses micro payments are not feasible. A business cannot charge 5 cents for a single API call because paying 20-30 cents in fees for a 5 cent transaction is not feasible. This limitation has forced businesses to bundle their services and offer them as a subscription model or use advertisements to support their income. 
  • Economic Incentive Misalignment: Many current business models profit from human inefficiency through complexity fees, forgetfulness (unused subscriptions), upselling, and dark patterns. Agents that ruthlessly optimize for users will destroy these revenue streams. Businesses must find new monetization models or they'll actively resist agent adoption.
  • Attention Economics Break Down: Current free internet business models monetize human attention through advertisements. Agents fundamentally break this model as they don't browse, scroll, or view ads. An agent comparing and shopping across 50 retailers executes in seconds with zero ad exposure. Businesses built on capturing and monetizing attention have no viable path to extract value from agent driven commerce.
  • Settlement: While the payment confirmation is instant, settlement can take days and is susceptible to fraud and chargebacks. Agents making thousands of microtransactions daily can't wait 3-5 days for funds to clear. They need instant finality to chain actions together.

Solving these challenges requires rethinking identity, payments, discovery, reputation and policy at the protocol level. X402, the open payment standard proposed by Coinbase, coupled with blockchain rails solves a part of the problem in the entire value chain. 

What is X402?

X402 is an open payment standard which enables AI agents and web services to autonomously pay for digital services (such as data access or API access) in real time without any human intervention. It also enables humans to pay using crypto-rails without going through an onboarding process.  

X402 transforms digital commerce by enabling instant, permissionless payments, turning every web service into a pay-per-use utility rather than a subscription or ad-supported platform.  

How does X402 work?

At its core, X402 works through a simple yet elegant request response flow:

  • Client Request: A user or AI agent makes an HTTP request to a protected resource
  • Payment Request from Server: If payment is required, the server responds with a 402 status code and payment details in the HTTP headers which include payment amount, network, supported tokens, wallet address etc. This eliminates the need for account creation, saved payment methods, or pre-authorization.
  • Payment and Re-try request: The client processes the payment on-chain using the payment details and makes the request again along with a signed payment authorization. On-chain payment with low fees allows micro payment which can be settled instantly. 
  • Payment verification and service access: Upon payment verification, the server provides access to the requested resource
    • By leveraging a facilitator, businesses don’t need to maintain direct blockchain connectivity or implement payment verification logic themselves. A facilitator verifies and settles payments and provides responses

Why is X402 a game changer?

  • Seamless Integration: The X402 standard uses the HTTP headers to communicate payment requirements, making it compatible with any existing web infrastructure.
  • Chain agnostic: The payments are chain agnostic allowing users or agents to use funds from any chain
  • Plug and Play: Integration is extremely simple because a single line of middleware or a configuration change in an existing web server stack enables X402 payments

X402 Adoption

X402 remains in its early adoption phase. As per data from X402scan, as of November 2, 2025, $7.04M in total value has flowed through the protocol across 10.63M transactions, an average of $0.66 per transaction. This validates the core micropayment thesis. These are precisely the kinds of small value transactions that traditional payment rails cannot handle economically. Notably, almost 98.5% of this volume has been processed in the last 15 days, reflecting that adoption is still in early stages.

The most prominent use case is data analytics platforms offering their insights programmatically via X402.

AInalyst, an agent launched on Virtuals, integrated X402 to enable programmatic access to its crypto intelligence data and analytics. It has emerged as the top service on X402, processing ~$350K in total value across 493K transactions. Canza, a web3 dashboard and analytics platform featuring customizable widgets and real-time data, has processed ~$215K across 434K transactions. Prixe, a stock price API allowing agents to create financial reports, plus various image and video generation endpoints, was among the first services to integrate X402 and list on X402 Bazaar. 

The modest volumes and simple use cases do not fully reflect X402’s true potential. They reflect the missing layers. Without mature identity systems, agents can't build persistent relationships. Without discovery protocols, they can't find services to pay for. Without reputation mechanisms, they can't evaluate which services are worth purchasing. X402 has solved how agents pay, but not yet what they pay for or why.

This is why the full stack matters. Payment infrastructure is necessary but not sufficient. The real unlock comes when identity, discovery, reputation, and governance mature alongside payments, creating a complete commerce environment where agents can operate autonomously and at scale.

Agentic commerce layer value chain

To fully realize the vision of an agentic society, we can think of agentic commerce through the lens of the agent lifecycle. When an agent needs to accomplish a task, whether booking travel, analyzing data, or financial planning, it moves through three fundamental stages: 

  1. Discovery & Reputation: Find and evaluate the right service
  2. Transaction & Delivery: Pay for, access, and verify service quality
  3. Personalization & Retention: Track, learn and improve from experience

Each stage requires specific technical infrastructure to function effectively. However, some capabilities provide essential support throughout the entire lifecycle. We organize the infrastructure into Core Lifecycle Layers (specific to each stage) and Cross-Cutting Layers (needed across all stages).

Core Lifecycle Infrastructure

These layers are specific to each stage of the agent's journey through commerce.

Stage 1: Discovery & Reputation

Find and evaluate the right service

Before an agent can transact, it must discover available services and evaluate which providers are trustworthy and suitable for its needs.

Layer Purpose Examples
Discovery & Registry Lets agents find APIs, datasets, services, and other agents autonomously. Without discovery, agent commerce remains closed and manual. X402 Bazaar, ERC 8004 registry, Virtuals ACP, Agentverse by Fetch.ai, OpenAPI registries, Mech marketplace by Olas.

Status: Nascent; metadata and schema standards still fragmented.
Reputation & Verification Measures reliability, honesty, and quality of agents or services. Without it, agents can’t choose trusted counter-parties. ERC 8004 Reputation Registry (reputation systems using client feedback) and Validation Registry, Virtuals ACP evaluator agents, Brevis (on-chain verifiability through zero-knowledge proofs), Recall Network (agents compete to prove performance), Eigen Layer (every agent operation is verified through economic security and validation infrastructure).

Status: Conceptual stage; small pilots using verifiable credentials and staking-based trust.

Stage 2: Transaction & Delivery

Pay for, access, and verify service quality

Once an agent selects a service, it must execute payment, gain authorized access, and verify that the service delivers as promised.

Layer Purpose Examples
Payment & Settlement Enables agents to make atomic, verifiable payments for access or services. X402, Agentic Commerce Protocol (ACP) by Stripe and OpenAI, Virtuals ACP, Google Agent Payments Protocol (AP2).

Status: Early experimentation and adoption phase.
Wallet & Custody Infrastructure Allows agents to securely hold assets and sign transactions. Without this, agents would need human intermediaries to manage keys, defeating autonomy. Coinbase Server Wallets, Circle Developer-Controlled Wallets, Turnkey, ZeroDev, Safe Smart Accounts, Lit PKPs, Privy server-side wallet, Vincent by Lit Protocol.

Status: Rapidly evolving and gaining adoption; MPC and smart account wallets integrating with agent SDKs.
Data Access & Authorization Enforces access control and content protection post-payment. Without this, paid content can’t be securely shared or limited. UCAN (User Controlled Authorization Networks) like Storacha Network, Lit Protocol (conditional decryption tied to payment proofs), Threshold Network’s TACo (enables time-limited or conditional access to encrypted content), single-use URLs, IP-restricted content streams.

Status: Active R&D; early frameworks like Lit already implement conditional decryption tied to payment proofs.

Stage 3: Learning & Optimization

Track, learn and improve from experience

After consuming services, agents accumulate performance data and user preferences to optimize future decisions and build long term value.

This stage encompasses two types of intelligence that agents build over time: 

  1. Service intelligence (tracking which providers deliver quality at what cost across thousands of interactions) 
  2. User intelligence (understanding personal preferences, behavioral patterns, and contextual needs). 

This stage is primarily about data accumulation and algorithmic optimization rather than protocol infrastructure. The value here comes from longitudinal data. Agents that learn become irreplaceable, creating switching costs through accumulated context. We explore this in more detail in the "Learning & Optimization" section of Value Capture in Agentic Commerce.

Cross-Cutting Infrastructure

These layers provide essential capabilities throughout the agent lifecycle, from initial discovery through post transaction learning.

Layer Purpose Examples
Identity & Authentication Provides agents with verifiable, persistent identifiers so they can be trusted, rate-limited, or recognized across interactions. Without this layer, every transaction is anonymous and stateless. This layer is not critical for one-time access. Agent2Agent by Google (identity and Auth by Auth0), Virtuals ACP (identity through cryptographic signatures & verifiable addresses), ERC-8004 Identity Register, Lit Protocol (to sign messages, prove identity, and enable decentralized machine-to-machine economy), Nuggets (Know your agent built on W3C standards and OIDCA), Fetch.ai Agentverse, SingularityNET and Privado ID agent identity, Universal Agent Identity Layer by LOKA Protocol.

Status: Early stage, fragmented but standards are maturing (W3C DID and Virtuals ACP).
Communication & Coordination Enables secure messaging, intent sharing, and task coordination among agents. Without this, commerce stays point-to-point. Examples: Google A2A, Virtuals ACP, XMTP, Model Context Protocol (MCP) by Anthropic.

Status: Fragmented; messaging protocols emerging.
Governance & Compliance Defines guardrails, dispute resolution, and regulatory adherence. Without this, agent commerce can’t scale legally or safely. Policy engines (Lit Actions), compliance-aware wallets, ZK proofs of compliance.

Status: Early but essential; compliance frameworks for agents still undefined.

Value Capture in Agentic Commerce

The real question for businesses and investors is: where do defensible business models emerge? Each stage of the agent lifecycle presents distinct opportunities for businesses to capture value, not by controlling the underlying protocols, but by solving the coordination, trust, and optimization problems that emerge at scale. The winners won't be those who simply implement standards or build basic registries. They'll be those who make agent commerce seamless, safe, and continuously improving.

  1. Discovery and Reputation: Truly autonomous agents will operate outside any siloes and across ecosystems. For these agents to operate across different ecosystems, discoverability and reputation will be extremely important.

    Historically, Google dominated discovery by offering search for free and monetizing user attention through advertisements. AI is already reshaping this landscape. Companies are now focusing on visibility in AI powered search engines like ChatGPT and ensuring their content appears in AI Overviews. There is early evidence of consumers, especially younger generations, relying on AI tools for search. According to a Vox Media survey, 34% of Gen Z now use AI chatbots like ChatGPT for search instead of traditional search engines.

    Given our thesis that agents will become the primary means for users to interact with the market, both businesses and autonomous agents will need a way to be visible to other agents and convince them to use their services. The real unlock comes when discovery becomes policy aware. Imagine an agent programmed to prioritize carbon-neutral suppliers or services under $10 per call. Discovery protocols that can filter and rank results based on an agent's programmed constraints will be far more valuable than simple search indexes.

    But this requires machine readable standards. Agents need to query products across platforms seamlessly with structured schemas (fabric, size, color for clothing; latency, uptime, pricing for APIs), real-time verifiable data, and interoperability across competing ecosystems. Schema.org standardized product data for the web but remained a free, open standard. The real value was captured by Google and other search engines, not by the standard itself.

    Agent discovery will be different. Because agents need real-time verification, reputation scoring, and policy-aware filtering, the discovery layer requires active infrastructure that can charge for value delivered. SWIFT standardized financial messaging and built a transaction based revenue model. Bloomberg standardized financial data and created a $10B+ business delivering it. Dun & Bradstreet standardized business identities and monetized verification services. These companies captured value by providing the infrastructure and delivery mechanisms that made standards useful. Any protocol that combines standardization with verification and reputation for agent discovery is likely to become indispensable in the growth of agentic commerce . 
  2. Transaction & Delivery: X402 establishes the payment protocol, but the standard itself is only the foundation, similar to how HTTP enabled the web but didn't capture value. The real opportunity lies in building the surrounding infrastructure that makes payments reliable, secure, and seamless at agent scale.

    Payment standards are commodities. Value accrues to those who solve the hard problems around them. Visa and Mastercard won by building dispute resolution and fraud detection. Stripe won by abstracting complexity and managing risk. However, agent commerce isn't just faster than human commerce. It is fundamentally different. Infrastructure designed for humans transacting dozens of times per month breaks when agents transact thousands of times per hour. Some of the missing Infrastructure Layers (Reimagined for Agents): 

    ⦿ Dispute Resolution & Transaction Guarantees: Traditional disputes take 30-90 days as humans file chargebacks with subjective complaints. Agent disputes must be resolved in milliseconds through programmatic verification: "API returned 500 error," "latency exceeded SLA." This requires real-time cryptographic verification, escrow, smart contracts verifying completion before releasing funds.
    ⦿ Fraud Detection & Risk Management: Stripe's radar detects unusual locations, velocity spikes, behavioral anomalies. These heuristics assume human behavior. An agent legitimately making 1,000 transactions per second looks identical to fraud. Geographic signals disappear as agents don't have a nationality.  Velocity limits break workflows. Agent fraud detection requires a fundamental shift from behavioral patterns to cryptographic authorization: can this agent prove it's authorized to act on its principal's behalf? Systems must verify delegation chains, enforce real-time spending limits, and detect anomalies tuned for machine behavior. Moreover, fraudsters will deploy agents to probe systems and find exploits. It's going to be AI versus AI. Businesses solving fraud at agent scale command premium pricing.
    ⦿ Compliance & Regulatory Orchestration: Stripe handles KYC for humans by verifying identity. Agent compliance requires "Know Your Agent", verifying authorization, not identity. The question isn't "who is this agent?" but "is this agent authorized to act on behalf of this human, and is that human compliant?" This means cryptographic proof of delegation chains and real-time sanctions screening across hundreds of counterparties per second.
    ⦿ Treasury & Liquidity Management: Stripe settles every 2-7 days. Agents need just-in-time liquidity to chain transactions, using Service A's response to immediately pay Service B. Agent treasury must be algorithmic and real-time. It should be able to predict liquidity spikes, auto-rebalance across chains, optimise gas fees, and generate yield on idle balances.
    ⦿ Developer Experience & Integration: Stripe won with seven line integration. Agent frameworks need similar simplicity, but must abstract authorization management, gas optimization, and cross-chain routing. Developers need SDKs handling agent specific complexity, sandboxes simulating transaction volumes, real-time dashboards for spending patterns, and pre-built integrations with agent frameworks. Value comes from stickiness because switching costs are high after integration.

    Existing Wallet Infrastructure and custody providers like Dynamic, Privy, and Safe handle key management and signing, enabling agents to hold and sign transactions. But they don't solve disputes, detect fraud, ensure compliance, or manage liquidity. The opportunity is building on top of custody to deliver complete financial services, treating wallets as table stakes while differentiating through risk, compliance, and treasury. The Value Hierarchy:

    ⦿ Bottom (commodity): Payment rails and protocols. X402 sits here.
    ⦿ Middle (competitive)
    : Basic processing and custody. Current wallet providers operate here.
    ⦿ Top (defensible)
    : Risk management, compliance, treasury, where Stripe, Visa, and Mastercard capture most value.

    Winners will implement X402 as table stakes, partner with wallet providers, but differentiate through superior risk management and financial services tuned for agent-scale commerce. The winner will take responsibility for speed and security, like how e-commerce platforms give guarantees and refunds

    Unknown Territory: Agent commerce introduces challenges we're still figuring out. When millions of agents optimize simultaneously, do markets exhibit novel instabilities like hallucinations, code injections, or smarter models finding ways to trick dumber agents? If an agent makes an illegal transaction, who's liable? Most critically, systemic risks may emerge that don't exist in human commerce. Failures propagating at machine speed, exploits draining agents globally within seconds, faster than human intervention. Businesses that anticipate these risks, building circuit breakers for algorithmic commerce, establishing liability frameworks, creating insurance for agent-specific risks are likely to capture outsized value.

    As agent volumes dwarf human commerce, even tiny fees compound massively. The key is solving problems that justify premium pricing: real-time trust, automated compliance, and financial intelligence agents genuinely need.

  1. Personalization & Retention: Lasting competitive advantage in agentic commerce comes from personalization. Agents that learn and improve over time become irreplaceable extensions of their users.

    Agents that accumulate experience build two types of knowledge that create defensible moats: service intelligence (which providers deliver quality at what cost) and user intelligence (what the human principal actually values). Unlike humans who use a service a few times before forming opinions, agents process vast performance data, tracking latency, accuracy, reliability, and cost across hundreds of providers, and continuously optimize selection. An agent that's evaluated 10,000 API calls across 50 providers knows far more about real world performance than any static review system.

    The deeper value comes from user data, years of accumulated history, preferences, and behavioral patterns that create switching costs growing over time. Unlike generic agents starting fresh with each interaction, specialized agents build irreplaceable context: your dietary restrictions and meal rotation patterns, communication style with different relationship tiers, spending psychology and financial goals, health history and recovery patterns, or how your music taste shifts with mood and time of day. The more decisions you delegate, the more valuable the agent becomes and the more painful switching to a competitor that knows nothing about you.

    This creates "data lock in" where value isn't just in the model or algorithms, but in cumulative understanding of you and your service ecosystem that no competitor can instantly replicate. A meal planning agent that's learned three years of your preferences is fundamentally more valuable than a technically superior competitor starting from scratch.

    The most powerful agents combine both dimensions through intelligent analysis of service performance data with deep personalization. An agent managing your schedule doesn't just pick the lowest latency calendar tool, it learns you're most productive in morning blocks, prefer video calls after 2pm, need 15-minute buffers, and historically cancel Friday afternoon commitments 40% of the time. It then selects and configures services optimized for your specific work patterns, not generic "best performance." This combination creates compounding insights unavailable from any single data source.

    Value capture: Agents with accumulated intelligence become sticky through switching costs, enabling subscription pricing that increases with tenure (more data = more value), revenue share with preferred services (agents drive repeated business), and premium tiers for advanced personalization. As agents accumulate data, they offer predictive services, proactively suggesting actions based on invisible patterns, creating additional monetization.

    Businesses that win own proprietary personalization engines that get smarter over time and trust frameworks convincing users to share intimate behavioral data. Early movers have compounding advantages. The agent capturing a user's first year has an edge over later entrants, creating winner-take-most dynamics in consumer agent markets.

End to End lifecycle

While businesses can capture value at individual stages, the most defensible position may be owning the entire lifecycle. By starting with deep specialization in a specific vertical, a project can also expand across the agent lifecycle, building an end to end ecosystem, capturing more value, and ultimately establishing dominance. Virtuals Protocol has built a society of agents, where agents can operate independently, discover, interact, communicate and negotiate with each other, assign tasks based on certain policies, evaluate the outcome while providing verifiability through on-chain record of agent-to-agent relationships. Virtuals Agent Commerce Protocol has generated over $100K in revenue in just three months since its July 2025 beta launch. Virtuals, however, runs on Base and Solana. Kite AI is attempting to go one step further by building a purpose built Layer 1 for AI combined with cryptographic identity, programmable governance, and native access to stablecoin transactions. Although attracting users and liquidity on a new settlement layer requires significant effort.

Conclusion

While crypto rails provide essential infrastructure for permissionless payments and programmable custody, they're only one piece of the puzzle. The agentic economy requires breakthroughs across multiple dimensions before reaching its trillion-dollar potential.

Model improvements are foundational. OpenAI has emphasized that reducing hallucinations remains stubbornly hard to fully solve. Improving reliability is critical for agents handling real transactions. Beyond accuracy, we need smaller, distilled models that run locally, on devices, at the edge, enabling privacy preserving personalization without sending intimate data to cloud providers. OpenAI’s latest research also shows that “It can be easier for a small model to know its limits.

Trust infrastructure extends beyond payments. Verification technologies like zkML and TEEs will become essential. Users need cryptographic proof their agent executed intended logic, not a compromised version. Service providers need verifiable guarantees that agents are authorized and compliant. These trust primitives are as important as payment rails for scaling agent commerce safely.

The digital physical bridge unlocks new markets. Robotics and autonomous systems will extend agentic commerce into the physical world. Agents will not only purchase products but coordinate delivery, assembly, and maintenance. Agents will negotiate, transact, and physically move goods end-to-end. This convergence represents the ultimate realization of autonomous commerce.

We're still early, but the direction is clear. Infrastructure is fragmented, standards are nascent, and many problems remain unsolved. Yet crypto's role is inevitable. When agents need to transact globally, instantly, and programmatically across untrusted parties, traditional rails with intermediaries, settlement delays, and geographic restrictions cannot scale. Crypto provides the only architecture matching requirements: permissionless access, instant finality, programmable logic, and global reach.

This creates a rare opportunity to leapfrog. Agentic commerce isn't upgrading existing systems but a new system built from scratch. The winners will be those solving coordination, trust, and optimization challenges that emerge when commerce operates at machine speed and scale. 

We'll continue exploring each layer in depth, the challenges, business models, and builders shaping agentic commerce. The race has just begun.